A thrilling final round of the Pool phase of the Investec Champions Cup provided a demonstration of both why the South African teams should aspire to be in the competition and also what they need to do if they are ever to compete for the most coveted trophy in club rugby.
While the local teams all exited the competition before the round of 16, the top French sides delivered a masterclass in what is required. Some other teams provided heroic performances that inspired the passion and emotion from their supporters which make this competition special.
There is bound to be a long post-mortem into the Sharks’ humiliating experience at the hands of the growing French giant that is the Bordeaux Begles. Two seasons ago the Sharks won an away game against Bordeaux, and for 11 heady minutes, it looked like they were going to repeat it against all the odds.
Two good tries put them 12-0 ahead and it quietened the electric atmosphere at the filled-to-capacity Stade Chaban-Delmas. But then it all unravelled for the Sharks and with French wing Damian Penaud providing a challenge to those who think his countryman Antoine Dupont is the GOAT (Greatest of all time) with six tries, the hosts dished out a rugby lesson.
It was a chastening experience for the Sharks, but given that the Durbanites weren’t the first ostensibly rated team to concede more than 60 points to Bordeaux, you have to ask the question - is everyone else really that bad, or are Bordeaux just particularly good?
That French rugby is on a different level was demonstrated immediately after the final whistle in Bordeaux. Toulouse were playing a strong Leicester Tigers, with Springbok flyhalf Handre Pollard among other top international players in tow, in a game that would determine whether Leicester get home advantage in the round of 16.
Leicester, captained by Argentina skipper Julian Montoya, was monstered by Dupont and the rest of the champion unit to the extent that they were trailing 42-0 at halftime. By full time Toulouse had gone beyond the 66 points scored by their countrymen in Bordeaux. They hit 80.
Yes, you can come down on the opposition and throw brickbats at them and accuse them of falling apart, but you also have to marvel at the sublime blend of skill and power packed by these uniquely gifted French teams. Both Bordeaux and Toulouse played to a level that went beyond any fitting superlatives. It was rugby from another planet.
Of course, as Vodacom Bulls coach Jake White might point out, comparing the South African sides with the elite French teams is not comparing apples with apples. There’s a massive difference in player budget, with the French teams not just driven by the best that country can offer but also in many cases the best the rest of the world can offer.
It’s not just the top French teams of the moment either. The Racing 92 team that beat the DHL Stormers by nine points at the La Defense Arena in Paris on Saturday night had former England captain and British and Irish Lions star Owen Farrell at flyhalf, but it was two big Fijians outside him that really won the game for their team. Former Stormers No8 Hacjivah Dayimani was in that position for Racing. And Racing is languishing at present in the Top 14.
But there appear to be fewer overseas stars driving the French teams than there were. Mainly because there are more French-produced stars coming through, as playing with and against international stars on a regular basis has to improve you.
SA has a veritable conveyor belt of talent coming through so the local teams, without quite the financial clout to attract the Galactico stars that the French clubs can, have to adopt a different approach. While the local sides have struggled this year, mainly because they were setback at the start of the competition and were always chasing the game after that, the upside is that talented youngsters like the Sharks’ exciting 20-year-old Jurenzo Julius have now tasted Champions Cup rugby.
So South Africans may just have to be patient in waiting for their teams to make up the yawning gap that has been opened up by the big-budget French teams. If there is patience, it should be rewarded, for this weekend did underline what a wonderful competition the Champions Cup is, with tight and tense finishes mixed with heroic efforts in a weekend where there was high jeopardy from the start, with Ulster forwarding their case with their big win over Exeter on Friday, through to the Sale Sharks making it by thrashing Toulon in the last game on Sunday.
The URC team from Treviso in Italy, Benetton, led the way on Saturday by reminding us, as the Stormers did last year, that the top French teams can be upset on a given day by beating La Rochelle. Few would have seen their win over two-time champions coming, and until a second-string Castres beat a full-strength Saracens at Saracens on Sunday, that was the upset of the weekend.
The Castres and Benetton performances were examples of what makes the Champions Cup so special, with players going onto a Test match footing in front of passionate fans and digging deep, going way beyond what you’d imagine a human being is capable of when it comes to physical effort.
While the Bulls were effectively playing a dead rubber at Loftus when they beat Stade Francais in front of 10,000 people at Loftus, however, the crowds in Durban and Cape Town the week before did indicate that local fans were starting to connect with the competition.
But not yet to the extent that the overseas crowds are, that will come with time. The heady atmosphere we witnessed in Bordeaux, and the previous evening when Leinster provided one of the statement performances of the weekend by thumping Bath in Dublin, with the Harlequins game against Glasgow Warriors also right up there, provided South Africans with a glimpse of what continued engagement with the Champions Cup can bring.
It’s going to require a lot of hard work across the board, that is what has become clear after a weekend where only the Bulls won and two teams, the Sharks and Bulls, made the drop to the EPCR Challenge Cup while the Stormers exited the competition completely because they finished bottom in their Pool. But if they achieve the growth of depth necessary to compete for silverware in the Champions Cup, what comes with that success both for the protagonists and their supporters will make the wait worthwhile.
Round of 16 (Weekend 4/5/6 April)
Bordeaux Begles vs Ulster
Northampton Saints vs Clermont-Auvergne
Leinster vs Harlequins
Glasgow Warriors vs Leicester Tigers
La Rochelle vs Munster
Toulon vs Saracens
Castres vs Benetton.
Toulouse vs Sale Sharks
Recent Posts
- Vodacom Bulls Made Several Changes For Vital DHL Stormers Clash
- Massive Clash In Wellington As Dames Look For Three In A Row At Home
- DHL Stormers Shuffle Backline To Host Vodacom Bulls In United Rugby Championship
- Easterby Names Ireland Team To Face Scotland In 2025 Guinness Six Nations
- England Named Team To Play France In 2025 Guinness Six Nations
- Venue Confirmed For Sevens Challenger 2025 Opener
- France Made Two Changes To Face England At Twickenham
- SARU To Appoint Independent Financial Advisors To Plot Future
- Wales Name Team To Face Italy In Round 2 Of 2025 Guinness Six Nations
- Most Of The Pressure Is On The DHL Stormers On Saturday
- Battle Lines Drawn In crucial Vodacom URC Derby In Cape Town
- How Do We Calculate The Top Rugby School Ranking?
- “Double Points” Make North-South Derby Win Important
- Joe McCarthy And Tadhg Furlong Ruled Out For Ireland’s Clash With Scotland
- Hollywoodbets Sharks Gives Update On Injured Players